Lacking a public option, the Max Baucus health care reform bill unveiled Wednesday has attracted a storm of criticism - with the strongest words coming from the left.
Health Care for America Now, the union-funded “grass roots” reform advocacy group had strong words for the bill.
Richard Kirsch, National Campaign Manager, Health Care for America Now declared the bill a “failure”:
The Baucus bill is a gift to the insurance industry that fails to meet the most basic promise of health care reform: a guarantee that Americans will have good health care that they can afford. The Baucus bill would give a government-subsidized monopoly to the private insurance industry to sell their most profitable plans - high-deductible insurance - without having to face competition from a public health insurer.
Atlantic.com’s Marc Ambinder picked up the HCAN line, pointing out that the group “and it’s member organizations have accounted for almost all of the activist and advertising push behind President Obama’s health care reform effort this summer.”
Ambinder doesn’t go after any reaction from the insurance industry to HCAN’s portrayal.
Daily Kos’s McJoan pulls former insurance exec Wendell Potter out of the woodwork to take another un-rebutted swipe at the industry and Baucus.
Who cares what some guy named Wendell Potter says? Anybody who’s been paying attention to the healthcare reform debate, because Mr. Potter is a former industry insider, a former Cigna executive, who’s guilty conscience has led to him to spill the beans about the worst of the industry practices.
“The Baucus framework is just an absolute joke,” said Potter, Cigna’s former head of corporate communications who has been speaking out against insurance industry practices. “It is an absolute gift to the industry. And if that is what we see in the legislation, (America’s Health Insurance Plans chief) Karen Ignagni will surely get a huge bonus.”
McJoan has this to say:
None of this comes as a surprise–Baucus is the best Democratic friend the industry has. That’s who saw the draft of the bill first, and it’s basically who wrote the thing in the first place.
So we know Max Baucus is representing his friends in industry instead of the American people. We’ll see how the rest of the Senate Dems and the White House come down on this.
The mainstream media’s pandering to HCAN can be seen in their stories Tuesday about the group’s million dollar ad buy attacking the industry.
Neither the Washington Post nor the New York Times bothered to get an insurance industry response to the ad. The times came closest by quoting an American Health Insurance Plans spokesman on the public option, but not a rebuttal of HCAN.